
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
Best for families and active travelers who want multiple pools, planned activities, varied on-site dining, and a signature aquarium restaurant.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds is a large, activity-forward Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach suited for families and groups who want pools, on-site dining, watersports, and entertainment. Anna Maria Beach Resort is a smaller beachfront hotel on Holmes Beach (Anna Maria Island) for travelers who prefer a calmer, island-style beach stay with straightforward amenities.
Updated

Best for families and active travelers who want multiple pools, planned activities, varied on-site dining, and a signature aquarium restaurant.

Best for travelers after a simple, Gulf-front room on Anna Maria Island with a private beach feel and low-rise, small-resort scale.
When RumFish Beach at TradeWinds wins: choose RumFish Beach if you want more on-site choices—four pools (including an adults-only pool), spa services, many dining venues (incl. the aquarium RumFish Grill), water-sports options, and family-oriented programming.
When Anna Maria Beach Resort wins: choose Anna Maria Beach Resort if you want a smaller, quieter beachfront hotel on Holmes Beach/Anna Maria Island with easy beach access, free on-site bicycles, and straightforward rooms for a low-key stay.
Bottom line: both properties put you on Gulf-front sand, but RumFish is the larger, amenity-rich and activity-forward option; Anna Maria Beach Resort is the simpler, island-style beachfront pick for travelers who prefer a calmer pace.
| Category | RumFish Beach at TradeWinds | Anna Maria Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, busy resort with lots of family activities and organized entertainment | Small, low-rise beachfront hotel with a quieter island feel |
| Location | Gulf-front on St. Pete Beach with easy access to city-center attractions | Beachfront on Holmes Beach, Anna Maria Island — island atmosphere |
| Size | Large resort (part of TradeWinds campus; hundreds of rooms, multiple event spaces) | Small hotel (31 rooms listed) |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family-oriented with a dedicated adults-only pool area | All ages (family-friendly) with a straightforward hotel operation |
| Pools & hot tubs | Multiple on-site pools (four outdoor pools reported) and two hot tubs, plus an adults-only pool | One outdoor pool and one hot tub listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Several on-site venues (RumFish Grill with 33,500-gallon aquarium, Gulfside Kitchen, sports bar, beach/pool bars) | Limited on-site dining; no signature restaurants listed in supplier facts |
| Spa & wellness | Serenity Sands Spa on site (massages, facials, nail services) and 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Aquarium dining (RumFish Grill), family activities, water sports, and event space | Private beach access, small scale, free on-site bicycles |
| Accessibility & service | 24-hour front desk, wheelchair-accessible rooms and facilities, on-site parking (surcharge) | Front desk with limited hours, free self-parking onsite (limited spaces) |
| Room types | Mix of standard rooms, studios and villa-style suites for groups and families (up to 6 in larger villas) | Oceanfront Pool View King/2 Queen rooms and several 1‑bedroom suites and luxury suites (31 rooms total) |
RumFish Beach sits directly on the Gulf-front sands of St. Pete Beach and is part of the larger TradeWinds resort campus.
RumFish is positioned for easy access to St. Pete Beach attractions and activities while offering a full resort footprint on the sand.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is a beachfront hotel on Holmes Beach, Anna Maria Island, with quick access to island beaches and local island attractions.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is for travelers who want to be on Anna Maria Island’s Gulf sand and don’t need a large resort complex.
RumFish Beach offers a broad range of room types including villa-style suites designed for families and groups.
Choose RumFish for flexible, family-friendly rooms and larger suite options.
Anna Maria Beach Resort operates a small collection of air-conditioned rooms and suites with oceanfront and pool-view options.
Anna Maria Beach Resort offers compact, well-equipped rooms aimed at travelers who want a simple beachfront stay.
RumFish Beach provides multiple on-site dining venues covering breakfast through late-night drinks and a signature aquarium restaurant.
Dining at RumFish is varied and built into the resort experience — good for guests who want choices without leaving the property.
Anna Maria Beach Resort has limited on-site food and beverage detail in its supplier listing; the property focuses on beach access and simple amenities.
Expect straightforward or off-property dining on Anna Maria Island unless you confirm on-site meal options directly with the hotel.
RumFish Beach emphasizes pools, beach activity, and unique aquarium experiences as core draws.
RumFish is built for active beach days and family programming, with pools and a standout aquarium experience.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is notable for private beach access and a single outdoor pool experience.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is focused on straightforward beachfront time rather than multiple pools or large-scale activity programming.
RumFish Beach offers an on-site spa, fitness center, and nightly entertainment options.
RumFish suits guests who want spa services, fitness options, and evening programming on property.
Anna Maria Beach Resort’s supplier listing includes basic outdoor social features but does not list a full spa or a nightlife program.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is better for low-key evenings and self-directed wellness than for an on-site spa-and-entertainment schedule.

RumFish Beach — multiple pools, kids’ programs, touch tank, watersports, and family-friendly dining.

Anna Maria Beach Resort — smaller property on Holmes Beach with private beach access and a calmer island pace.

RumFish Beach — RumFish Grill’s aquarium dining and several bars/restaurants on property.

Anna Maria Beach Resort — compact room inventory, free bicycles, and direct beach access for straightforward stays.
RumFish Beach is geared toward families with multiple pools, kids’ activities, a touch tank, and family-friendly dining. Anna Maria Beach Resort is more low-key and may suit families who prefer quiet beach time.
Anna Maria Beach Resort rooms include refrigerators and microwaves per the supplier listing. RumFish Beach room types range up to villa-style units; confirm the presence of kitchenettes for a specific room type when booking.
RumFish Beach has an on-site Serenity Sands Spa. Anna Maria Beach Resort’s supplier listing does not publish a full-service spa.
RumFish Beach has several on-site venues (including RumFish Grill with an aquarium). Anna Maria Beach Resort’s listing does not show a signature full-service restaurant.
Explore how RumFish Beach at TradeWinds stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·