
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
Best for families and active beachgoers who want pools, organized beach activities and multiple on-site dining choices.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds is a family-focused Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach with multiple pools, beachfront dining and an on-site aquarium. Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection is a smaller, marina-focused Autograph Collection property on Anna Maria Island—read this if you’re deciding between a lively beachfront family resort and a quieter villa-and-marina option.
Updated

Best for families and active beachgoers who want pools, organized beach activities and multiple on-site dining choices.

Best for travelers who prefer a quieter island villa feel with a marina and self-catering kitchen facilities.
When RumFish Beach at TradeWinds wins: choose RumFish Beach if you want direct Gulf-front sand, a wide range of family activities (kayak/paddleboard, dolphin and fishing tours), multiple swimming pools including an adults-only pool, and several on-site restaurants including the aquarium-side RumFish Grill.
When Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection wins: pick Waterline if you prefer villa accommodations with full kitchens, a small-property, branded-boutique feel and direct marina access for boating or private watercraft.
Bottom line: RumFish Beach is the busier, activity-forward beachfront resort suited to families and groups; Waterline Villas & Marina is the smaller, quieter marina-centered Autograph Collection choice for travelers who want villa-style rooms and water access from Anna Maria Island.
| Category | RumFish Beach at TradeWinds | Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively family beachfront resort with resort activities and evening entertainment | Marina-focused, villa-style Autograph Collection property with quieter island feel |
| Location | 6000 Gulf Blvd, St. Pete Beach — directly on Gulf-front sand | 5325 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach — waterfront on Anna Maria Island with marina and dock |
| Size | Approximately 352 guest rooms across the TradeWinds campus (RumFish Beach listing and shared campus venues) | 37 individually furnished guestrooms (villas) |
| Guests / age policy | All ages welcome; children 17 and under stay free when sharing a room; one registered adult (21+) required | All ages welcome; not adults-only (minimum age to register not published here) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Four outdoor pools (including an adults-only pool) plus two hot tubs | Number of outdoor pools - 1 (per supplier listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | Five on-site venues including RumFish Grill (aquarium dining), Gulfside Kitchen, sports bar and beachfront bars | One on-site restaurant (The Chateau Anna Maria) and a bar/lounge; room service limited hours |
| Spa & fitness | Serenity Sands Spa on site (massages, facials, nail services) plus 24-hour fitness and beach yoga | Health or beauty spa nearby (not listed as a full on-site spa); has 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | 33,500‑gallon aquarium at RumFish Grill and family-oriented beach programming | Marina and dock access, villa-style rooms with full kitchens |
| Rooms — typical features | Range of rooms and villas for families and groups (multiple room types, larger villa-style suites available) | Individually furnished 2‑bedroom villas and Grand Villa options with kitchens and double‑sofa beds |
| Meetings & events | Extensive meeting and wedding spaces across the TradeWinds campus (many outdoor and indoor venues) | Smaller property with two meeting rooms and wedding services; more limited event footprint |
RumFish Beach sits directly on the Gulf-front sand at 6000 Gulf Blvd on St. Pete Beach.
Choose RumFish for immediate Gulf-front beach access and easy access to busy St. Pete Beach attractions.
Waterline Villas & Marina is a waterfront Autograph Collection property on Anna Maria Island at 5325 Marina Drive.
Choose Waterline if you want an island-marine setting with direct dock access and a quieter island pace.
RumFish Beach offers a mix of rooms and villa-style suites sized for families and groups.
RumFish has more variety for families and groups needing extra beds and suite space.
Waterline focuses on villa-style accommodations, most with two bedrooms and kitchens.
Waterline suits travelers who want a self-contained villa with kitchen space and more privacy.
RumFish Beach provides multiple on-site dining and drinking venues across casual to full-service seafood dining.
RumFish is better if you want several on-site dining options and evening entertainment without leaving the property.
Waterline has one main on-site restaurant (The Chateau Anna Maria) and a bar/lounge.
Waterline fits travelers who prefer villa kitchens or a quiet single-restaurant setup rather than a multi-venue resort.
RumFish Beach emphasizes pools and beachfront programming, plus a large on-site aquarium dining experience.
RumFish is for guests who prioritize pools, beach activities and a unique aquarium attraction.
Waterline’s standout amenity is its marina and dock access rather than multiple pools or beachfront programming.
Waterline is better for boating and marina-focused stays rather than a resort pool-and-beach activity program.
RumFish Beach offers an on-site spa, 24-hour fitness and an active evening program oriented toward families and groups.
RumFish has both wellness services and family-friendly nightlife activities on property.
Waterline lists fitness facilities and a health/beauty spa nearby rather than a full-service on-site spa.
Waterline is quieter at night and better for low-key wellness or independent spa visits off property.

RumFish Beach — multiple pools (including an adults-only option), kids’ touch tank and family activities like beach yoga and water-sports programming.

Waterline — on-site marina, dock and availability of personal motorized watercraft make it the better pick for boaters.

RumFish Beach — RumFish Grill’s 33,500‑gallon aquarium plus a paid 'Swim with the Fishes' experience.

Waterline — two-bedroom villas with full kitchens and living areas suited to longer stays or self-catered meals.
RumFish Beach — it has dedicated family pools, a kids’ touch tank, family activities and children 17 and under stay free when sharing a room.
Waterline Villas & Marina has an on-site marina and dock; RumFish arranges boat tours and water activities but does not list an on-site marina dock as a primary feature.
RumFish Beach — multiple venues (RumFish Grill, Gulfside Kitchen, RumFish Sports Bar & Deck, SandBar, The Cabana Bar) versus Waterline’s single main restaurant and bar/lounge.
RumFish Beach has Serenity Sands Spa on site; Waterline’s listing indicates a health or beauty spa nearby rather than a full-service on-site spa.
Explore how RumFish Beach at TradeWinds stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·