
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
Best for families and travelers who want multiple pools, on-site activities (including an aquarium experience), and more dining options on property.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds is a larger, family-focused Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach with multiple pools, an on-site spa, and an aquarium-dining experience. Surf Beach Treasure Island Resort is a smaller, casual beachfront aparthotel on Treasure Island for travelers wanting simple condo-style rooms and easy access to John's Pass.
Updated · about 9 miles apart

Best for families and travelers who want multiple pools, on-site activities (including an aquarium experience), and more dining options on property.

Best for travelers who want a simple, condo-style beachfront stay on Treasure Island close to John's Pass Village.
When RumFish Beach at TradeWinds wins: choose RumFish for a bigger resort experience — more pools (including an adults-only pool), multiple on-site restaurants and bars, a full spa (Serenity Sands Spa), organized beach and water activities, and unique aquarium dining.
When Surf Beach Treasure Island Resort wins: pick Surf Beach for a quieter, smaller-scale beachfront aparthotel with condo-style rooms (kitchens), free self-parking, a single outdoor pool and hot tub, and very close access to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk.
Bottom line: RumFish is the better pick for families or groups wanting resort amenities, varied dining, and activities. Surf Beach Treasure Island Resort is a practical, lower-key choice for travelers who prioritize simple beachfront lodging near John's Pass.
| Category | RumFish Beach at TradeWinds | Surf Beach Treasure Island Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Larger, family-friendly Gulf-front resort with many on-site activities and restaurants | Small, casual beachfront aparthotel with condo-style rooms |
| Location | 6000 Gulf Blvd, St. Pete Beach — directly on St. Pete Beach sand | 11040 Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island — directly on Treasure Island beachfront |
| Size (rooms) | About 352 guest rooms (part of the larger TradeWinds campus) | 30 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages (family-friendly) with a dedicated adults-only pool area | All ages — not adults-only |
| Pools & hot tubs | Four outdoor pools (including 1 adults-only) and two hot tubs | One outdoor pool and one hot tub |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues including RumFish Grill (33,500-gallon aquarium), Gulfside Kitchen, SandBar, Cabana Bar, RumFish Sports Bar | No signature on-site restaurants listed; rooms include kitchens (Deluxe Condo, Family Condo names shown) |
| Spa & fitness | Serenity Sands Spa on-site; 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Aquarium dining (RumFish Grill) and family activities / water sports | Close access to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk and simple condo-style beachfront units |
| Parking | Self-parking available for a nightly surcharge (paid on site) | Free self parking available onsite (limited spaces) |
| Accessibility | Elevator access and wheelchair-accessible rooms and facilities | Wheelchair-accessible pool, paths, parking and elevator access noted |
RumFish Beach sits directly on the Gulf-front sands of St. Pete Beach at 6000 Gulf Blvd.
Choose RumFish if you want a larger St. Pete Beach resort setting with more on-site options.
Surf Beach Treasure Island Resort is a small beachfront aparthotel at 11040 Gulf Blvd on Treasure Island.
Choose Surf Beach for straightforward beachfront access near John’s Pass and local shops.
RumFish Beach offers a mix of rooms, studios and villa-style accommodations to suit families and groups.
RumFish is aimed at families or groups who need flexible, larger rooms and suites.
Surf Beach lists condo-style guestrooms with kitchen facilities and balcony options.
Surf Beach suits travelers who want in-room kitchens and a compact property footprint.
RumFish Beach provides several on-site dining venues, anchored by RumFish Grill and its large aquarium.
RumFish is better if you want varied on-site eating and themed dining experiences.
Surf Beach emphasizes condo kitchens and simple on-site amenities rather than multiple restaurants.
Surf Beach works well for guests who prefer to cook or keep dining low-key.
RumFish Beach highlights four outdoor pools, two hot tubs, and its aquarium-focused activities.
RumFish is built around pools, beach programming and the on-site aquarium attraction.
Surf Beach offers a single outdoor pool and a hot tub plus direct beach access.
Surf Beach is a simpler beachfront stay focused on the beach and condo-style convenience.
RumFish Beach provides a full-service spa, fitness options, and nightly entertainment.
RumFish is the pick for on-site spa treatments and a livelier evening scene.
Surf Beach focuses on low-key evenings and self-directed wellness at the unit level.
Surf Beach is better for guests who want quiet evenings or who plan to visit nearby bars and restaurants.

RumFish — multiple pools, villa-style rooms for larger groups, children’s activities and shared resort programming.

Surf Beach — condo kitchens, small property footprint, and close proximity to John's Pass Village.

RumFish — aquarium dining at RumFish Grill plus several bars and themed drink events.

Surf Beach — full kitchens in units and free self parking (limited spaces) on site.
RumFish Beach is the clearer family option: more pools, kids’ activities, a touch tank, and larger suites that accommodate families.
Yes — Surf Beach lists condo units with full-sized refrigerators and ovens. Some RumFish villa-style units may include kitchen-style amenities but the property emphasizes on-site dining.
RumFish has an on-site spa (Serenity Sands Spa). Surf Beach does not publish an on-site spa in the supplier listing.
Surf Beach is much closer to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk; RumFish is farther south on St. Pete Beach.
Explore how RumFish Beach at TradeWinds stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·