
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
Best for families and beach-focused travelers who want pools, water sports, on-site kids’ activities and direct Gulf sand access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds is a family-focused Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach with multiple pools, beachfront dining, water sports and an aquarium-themed signature restaurant. The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club, Autograph Collection is a historic, downtown St. Petersburg luxury hotel with golf-club branding, multiple restaurants, a spa and meeting space — read this if you’re choosing between beachfront family time and a landmark city resort experience.
Updated · about 19 km apart

Best for families and beach-focused travelers who want pools, water sports, on-site kids’ activities and direct Gulf sand access.

Best for travelers who prefer a historic downtown luxury stay with a full-service spa, on-site golf programming and easy access to St. Petersburg’s museums and nightlife.
When RumFish Beach at TradeWinds wins: choose RumFish Beach if your priority is Gulf-front sand, lots of on-site family activities (pools, touch tank, swim-with-the-fish aquarium experience), beachfront dining and water-sport options.
When The Vinoy wins: choose The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club if you want a landmark downtown St. Petersburg address, a traditional resort experience with a spa, golf driving range/lessons on site, multiple restaurants and a larger meetings/events footprint.
Bottom line: pick RumFish Beach for beach-first, multi-generational stays and active water experiences; pick The Vinoy for historic downtown luxury, golf and event-oriented travel.
| Category | RumFish Beach at TradeWinds | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, family-focused Gulf-front resort with active programming and multiple pools | Historic, formal luxury resort anchored in downtown St. Petersburg with golf-club branding |
| Location | Directly on St. Pete Beach Gulf-front sand (6000 Gulf Blvd) | Downtown St. Petersburg, near Vinoy Park and St. Pete Pier (501 5th Ave NE) |
| Size (rooms) | 352 guest rooms (TradeWinds campus listings; RumFish Beach portion listed in property profiles) | 356 guestrooms |
| Guests | All ages; family-friendly with dedicated adults-only pool area | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools | Four outdoor pools (including an adults-only pool) plus two hot tubs | Two outdoor pools |
| Beach access | Direct Gulf-front beach access with loungers, umbrellas and towels included in resort amenities | Vinoy Park and a small beach area nearby (Vinoy Park Beach) — not the same as a Gulf-front resort |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (RumFish Grill aquarium restaurant, Gulfside Kitchen, RumFish Sports Bar & Deck, SandBar, The Cabana Bar, coffee counter) | Multiple restaurants and bars (6 restaurants, 4 bars/lounges, including Paul's Landing and poolside bar) |
| Spa & wellness | Serenity Sands Spa on-site, fitness center open 24/7 and guided beach yoga | Full-service spa, fitness facilities, steam room and Pilates classes on site |
| Meetings & events | Extensive outdoor and indoor venues for weddings and meetings across the TradeWinds campus (multiple terraces, lawn, ballrooms) | Large conference center with 21 meeting rooms and ~74,897 sq ft of event space |
| Signature feature | 33,500‑gallon aquarium at RumFish Grill and swim-with-the-fishes experience | Historic Mediterranean-style property with golf driving range, marina access and landmark status |
RumFish Beach sits directly on the Gulf-front sand of St. Pete Beach, built around beach access and water activities.
Choose RumFish for an on-the-sand beach stay and easy access to water-based activities.
The Vinoy sits in downtown St. Petersburg beside Vinoy Park and the St. Pete Pier area, within easy reach of museums and theaters.
Choose The Vinoy if you want a central, city-side base for museums, dining and waterfront promenades.
RumFish Beach offers a mix of rooms and villa-style suites sized for families and groups.
RumFish rooms prioritize family occupancy and Gulf-front sightlines in some villa categories.
The Vinoy’s inventory is a mix of historic guest rooms and newer tower/bay-view rooms and suites.
The Vinoy suits travelers who want historic-room character or upgraded bay-view/tower suites with traditional luxury touches.
RumFish Beach focuses on Gulf-to-table seafood, casual beachfront menus and family-friendly dining.
RumFish emphasizes seafood, beachfront dining and lively, family-oriented bars and events.
The Vinoy offers several restaurants and bars covering American and resort-style dining across the property.
The Vinoy is a fit for travelers looking for formal dining options and multiple on-site outlets within a historic resort setting.
RumFish Beach centers guest life around pools, beach and the aquarium dining/shelling experiences.
RumFish is built for beach-and-pool days plus family-focused water attractions.
The Vinoy’s notable on-site amenities include two outdoor pools, a marina and golf-related facilities.
The Vinoy is more oriented to traditional resort leisure — pool, spa and golf — rather than beach activity.
RumFish balances wellness with family entertainment and beach fitness.
RumFish mixes spa and fitness with active, family-oriented evening entertainment.
The Vinoy provides a traditional spa-and-wellness program and a quieter, more polished evening scene tied to downtown dining and events.
The Vinoy fits travelers who want a polished spa experience and walkable access to city nightlife and cultural events.

RumFish Beach — direct Gulf-front beach access, four pools, kids’ touch tank and family-sized villas make it the easier pick for multi-generational beach stays.

The Vinoy — choose it for a landmark hotel experience in the heart of St. Petersburg with bay-view rooms and a long-standing reputation.

RumFish Beach — on-site swim-with-the-fishes aquarium events, paddleboarding, kayaking and arranged dolphin cruises keep guests on the water.

The Vinoy — extensive indoor meeting rooms plus a conference center and large banquet footprint suit corporate and large-group needs.
RumFish Beach — it’s explicitly family-friendly with multiple pools, kids’ activities, touch tank experiences and larger villa-style rooms.
The Vinoy — it’s centrally located beside Vinoy Park and within walking distance of the Museum of Fine Arts, St. Pete Pier and downtown restaurants.
The Vinoy offers on-site golf programming, a driving range and golf services; RumFish Beach is focused on beach and water activities rather than an on-site golf course.
Yes. RumFish Beach has Serenity Sands Spa and The Vinoy offers a full-service spa; check each property’s reservation policy for treatments and booking requirements.
Explore how RumFish Beach at TradeWinds stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·