
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
Best for families and groups who want multiple pools, organized activities, water-sports options and a lively on-site dining scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds is a large, activity-focused, family-friendly Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach; this comparison is for travelers who want lots of on-site pools, kids' activities and distinctive dining. The Avalon Club is an upscale beachfront-style resort hotel on Clearwater Beach with high guest ratings — read this if you want a smaller, more tranquil beachfront base near Clearwater attractions.
Updated · about 17 miles (27 km) apart

Best for families and groups who want multiple pools, organized activities, water-sports options and a lively on-site dining scene.

Best for travelers who want a smaller, upscale beachfront-style hotel on Clearwater Beach with high guest ratings and simple, apartment-style suites.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds wins when you want a wide range of on-site activities (kayaking, paddleboarding, dolphin and fishing excursions), multiple pools (including an adults-only pool), a full-service spa and several distinct dining and bar venues — plus the aquarium-dining experience.
The Avalon Club wins when you prefer a smaller, apartment-style resort on Clearwater Beach with fewer guests, fewer on-site venues to navigate, and very strong guest scores — a quieter base for exploring Clearwater Beach itself.
Bottom line: choose RumFish Beach for a bigger, action-oriented Gulf-front resort that suits families and groups; choose The Avalon Club for an upscale, compact Clearwater Beach stay with high guest ratings and simpler on-site facilities.
| Category | RumFish Beach at TradeWinds | The Avalon Club |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, family- and activity-driven resort with many on-site venues and programmed activities. | Upscale, compact beachfront-style aparthotel with a quieter, low-key feel. |
| Location | Directly on the Gulf-front sands of St. Pete Beach (6000 Gulf Blvd). | On Clearwater Beach (24 Avalon St), steps from the beach and Pier 60 area. |
| Size | Large resort campus (RumFish Beach + access to Island Grand facilities); 352 guest rooms on the RumFish/TradeWinds campus. | Small property — 34 rooms (aparthotel-style). |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-focused with a dedicated adults-only pool area. | All ages (not adults-only); appeals to couples and small groups preferring an upscale stay. |
| Pools & hot tubs | Four outdoor pools (including 1 adults-only) plus two hot tubs; pool hours commonly 7:00 a.m.–11:00 p.m. | Number of outdoor pools - 1. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: RumFish Grill (aquarium dining), Gulfside Kitchen, RumFish Sports Bar & Deck, SandBar, Cabana Bar, plus coffee counter. | On-site snack bar/deli, 1 bar/lounge and 1 coffee shop/cafe listed; fewer full-service restaurants on property. |
| Spa & wellness | Serenity Sands Spa on-site (massages, facials, nail services) with beach-cabana options; 24-hour fitness center and beach yoga. | Not published |
| Known for | 33,500-gallon aquarium with dining beside it and a paid 'Swim with the Fishes' experience; broad program of water sports and activities. | High guest rating (9.4) and immediate Clearwater Beach access — good visibility for Clearwater attractions. |
| Parking & transport | Self-parking available on site (surcharge) and shuttle/transport options; nearest major airport PIE ~12.6 miles. | Covered parking / secured parking available; self parking (surcharge). |
RumFish Beach sits directly on the Gulf-front sands of St. Pete Beach and is part of the larger TradeWinds campus.
Choose RumFish for a classic St. Pete Beach beachfront location with on-site water activities and easy island/beach access.
The Avalon Club sits on Clearwater Beach, a short walk to Pier 60 and the beach walk attractions.
Choose The Avalon Club for direct Clearwater Beach access and proximity to Pier 60 attractions.
RumFish Beach offers a mix of rooms, studios and villa-style suites that accommodate families and groups.
RumFish provides more large-suite and family-capacity options than a small aparthotel.
The Avalon Club features apartment-style suites across one- and multi-bedroom options.
The Avalon Club suits travelers who want suite-style rooms with kitchens and a compact property footprint.
RumFish Beach provides multiple on-site dining venues covering seafood, casual Gulf-side meals, sports-bar energy and beachfront bars.
RumFish is best if you want several distinct dining styles and on-site evening entertainment options.
The Avalon Club has a smaller on-site food-and-drink footprint with a coffee shop/cafe and a bar/lounge plus a snack bar/deli.
The Avalon Club is better if you prefer suite kitchens and limited on-site dining, relying more on nearby Clearwater Beach restaurants.
RumFish Beach centers on beach access, multiple pools and unique aquarium experiences.
RumFish is the choice for varied pool options, beach programming and a distinctive aquarium attraction.
The Avalon Club lists a single outdoor pool and immediate Clearwater Beach access.
The Avalon Club suits travelers who want a straightforward beach stay and easy walks to Clearwater Beach attractions.
RumFish Beach offers a full spa, 24-hour fitness and nightly entertainment options on site.
Pick RumFish if you want on-site spa services, fitness and active evening programming.
The Avalon Club lists fitness facilities and accessible amenities; spa details are not published in the supplier listing.
Avalon works for travelers who want a compact stay with concierge help for local activities; spa details should be confirmed directly.

RumFish Beach — multiple pools, kids' activities, larger suite options and family programming.

The Avalon Club — smaller property on Clearwater Beach with a quieter, upscale apartment-style feel.

RumFish Beach — aquarium dining at RumFish Grill and a paid 'Swim with the Fishes' experience.

The Avalon Club — many suites include full kitchens and larger in-room appliances.
RumFish Beach — it has multiple family pools, a touch tank, extensive kid-friendly activities and larger family suite options.
The Avalon Club — it’s on Clearwater Beach and listed as a short walk to Pier 60 Park and the Beach Walk area.
The supplier listing for The Avalon Club does not publish a spa; confirm with the property directly if a spa or on-site treatments are a priority.
RumFish Beach offers a paid 'Swim with the Fishes' aquarium snorkeling experience; The Avalon Club listing does not show an equivalent on-site activity.
Explore how RumFish Beach at TradeWinds stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·