
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds
Best for families or groups who want a large Gulf-front resort with multiple pools, restaurants, and organized activities on site.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
RumFish Beach at TradeWinds is a large, activity-packed Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach with multiple pools, dining venues, a spa, and family-focused programming; read this if you want a full-service beach resort with lots of on-site options. Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages is a casual beachfront cottage property on Holmes Beach; read this if you want a lower-key Anna Maria Island stay in individually decorated rooms and cottages.
Updated

Best for families or groups who want a large Gulf-front resort with multiple pools, restaurants, and organized activities on site.

Best for travelers seeking a quieter, cottage-style beachfront stay on Holmes Beach with individually decorated rooms and basic on-site conveniences.
When RumFish Beach at TradeWinds wins: choose RumFish if you want a full-service resort experience — multiple pool options (including an adults-only pool), many on-site restaurants and bars, a 33,500-gallon aquarium dining experience, and organized beach and water activities.
When Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages wins: pick Cedar Cove for a simpler, low-key Anna Maria Island beachfront stay in individually decorated cottages and suites, because the property keeps things casual and centered on a smaller, local-beach atmosphere.
Bottom line: RumFish is a big, amenity-rich resort that suits families and guests who plan to spend most of their time on property. Cedar Cove is a smaller, more relaxed beachfront option for those who prefer cottage-style rooms and a quieter Holmes Beach base.
| Category | RumFish Beach at TradeWinds | Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, activity-focused Gulf-front resort with resort-wide programming | Casual, cottage-style beachfront property with individually decorated rooms |
| Location | St. Pete Beach — directly on Gulf-front sand | Holmes Beach — beachfront on Anna Maria Island |
| Size / rooms | About 352 guest rooms across the TradeWinds campus (RumFish Beach component large resort property) | 19 individually decorated guestrooms and cottages |
| Who it's for | Families, groups, guests who want on-site dining, pools, activities, and a spa | Couples, small families, and travelers seeking a lower-key cottage stay on Holmes Beach |
| Pools | Four outdoor pools and two hot tubs, including an adults-only pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: RumFish Grill (aquarium dining), Gulfside Kitchen, RumFish Sports Bar & Deck, SandBar, Cabana Bar, coffee counter | Not a large dining campus; no signature on-site restaurants listed in the supplier listing |
| Spa & wellness | Serenity Sands Spa on site (massages, facials, nail services) plus 24-hour fitness center and beach yoga | Not published |
| Known for | 33,500-gallon aquarium dining experience and 'Swim with the Fishes' add-on | Individually decorated cottage rooms and central Holmes Beach location near Bradenton Beach |
| Parking & transport | On-site self-parking (fee); shuttle and transfer options noted in resort materials | Free self parking available on site |
| Family-friendly | Yes — family programs, children's activities, children 17 and under stay free | Yes — property lists children's toys and games among amenities |
RumFish Beach sits directly on the Gulf-front sands of St. Pete Beach with easy access to local St. Pete Beach attractions.
Choose RumFish for a lively Gulf-front location with resort-scale access to local attractions.
Cedar Cove is a small beachfront resort-and-cottage property centrally located in Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island.
Choose Cedar Cove for a straightforward Holmes Beach location if you want Anna Maria Island’s quieter beach scene.
RumFish offers a range of rooms and villa-style suites designed for families and groups, with multiple room categories on a larger resort campus.
RumFish is the better fit if you need more space options or villas for family or group stays.
Cedar Cove lists 19 individually decorated guestrooms and cottages, from studios to multi-bedroom suites and named cottages.
Cedar Cove works well if you value a cottage-like room with kitchen facilities and independent style.
RumFish offers a range of on-site dining venues from casual to full-service seafood beside an aquarium.
RumFish is the choice for guests who want multiple on-site dining and nightlife options without leaving the property.
Cedar Cove does not list multiple signature restaurants in the supplier listing and is positioned as a low-key beachfront property.
Cedar Cove is best if you prefer to eat out locally or cook in a room kitchen rather than rely on resort dining.
RumFish’s pool and beach offering is a major part of the property, with several pool options and direct beach access.
If pools, beach activities, and dedicated adult and family pool spaces matter, RumFish leads here.
Cedar Cove is a beachfront cottage property focused on simple beach access rather than an on-site pool complex.
Cedar Cove is about beach access and a quieter stay rather than multiple resort pools.
RumFish offers a full spa, fitness center and a steady lineup of evening entertainment.
RumFish fits travelers who want on-site spa treatments, fitness facilities, and nighttime entertainment.
Cedar Cove lists some family-friendly and outdoor amenities but does not publish a spa or nightlife program in its listing.
Cedar Cove is better for guests who want low-key evenings and local dining rather than on-site nightlife or spa facilities.

RumFish — multiple pools, kids’ activities, touch tank, aquarium experiences, and family-friendly dining.

Cedar Cove — small property with individually decorated cottages and suites on Holmes Beach.

RumFish — five distinct dining venues from breakfast to late-night drinks, plus the aquarium dining room.

Cedar Cove — many rooms include kitchens and the property offers free self parking.
RumFish — its larger rooms and villas, multiple pools, children’s activities, and family dining options make it easier to keep different ages entertained on site.
Cedar Cove — it’s a smaller cottage-style beachfront property on Holmes Beach and keeps the atmosphere more relaxed.
The supplier listing for Cedar Cove does not publish an on-site spa or signature multiple restaurants; RumFish lists a full spa and several dining venues including RumFish Grill.
Yes. RumFish is explicitly family-focused with kid activities and children-stay-free policies; Cedar Cove’s listing includes children’s games and toys and does not enforce an adults-only policy.
Explore how RumFish Beach at TradeWinds stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·